
- Typology
- Hospitality
- Components
- Marina / Yacht Club, Resort / Hotel, Resort Community, Single Family, Spa / Wellness
- Attributes
- Destination Creation, Island, Sustainability, Waterfront
- Scale
- 230 acres, 193,848 ft² built, 60-slip marina, 37 hilltop bungalows, 2,500 m² spa, 5,000 ft² retail and commercial




scrubbed hulls, bare hill the resort gathered at the lee the north beach left alone
Place
Place: Reached by water
You reach Scrub Island by water. It sits off the north-east coast of Tortola in the British Virgin Islands, 230 acres of steep green hillside with a sheltered anchorage on its lee, and for most of its history nothing else. The name is four centuries old and comes from what the place was for: when these islands were a haven for pirates and buccaneers, crews hauled their boats onto the shallows here and scrubbed the barnacles from the hulls before heading back out to sea. Three and a half centuries later, the island was still bare, with no road, no water, no power, nothing at all.

Approach
Approach: Gathered on the lee side
OBMI master planned the island from that starting point, and the brief carried a tension. The developers needed a scheme that worked financially; the island’s value lay in being untouched. OBMI’s answer was to concentrate the development rather than spread it, gathering the resort around a marina on the sheltered lee side and stepping residences into the hillside above it, so that large areas of the island could be left alone entirely. The north side, which holds the best beach, was kept almost bare, with nothing on it but a small beach bar. The marina became the island’s entry point and the anchor of the design, with the architecture around it drawn from the fishing villages of the region and detailed in a mix of West Indian and Mediterranean traditions.




Experience
Experience: Rain, sun and local hands
Working on a remote island shaped the practical decisions as much as the aesthetic ones. Small portions of coral reef were relocated with marine specialists so nothing of the reef was lost. Roofs catch rainwater into cisterns for irrigation, solar power supplies the resort, and the design accounts for the steep topography and its run-off to the sea. Hurricane resistance and passive cooling are built into the structures. Local contractors were engaged from the outset, working in materials and techniques they knew, which kept the resort rooted in the place.

Outcome
Outcome: Further up the hill
The resort opened as the first new development of its kind in the British Virgin Islands in more than fifteen years, and became the first in the Caribbean to join Marriott’s Autograph Collection. Mainsail returned to OBMI afterwards to extend it, adding thirty-seven hilltop bungalows stepped around the hillside in phases, with lagoon pools below, each set into the terrain for privacy and the long view out.
“OBMI brought us the creative vision for the design of this resort community and then backed that up with a practical understanding of how to translate the vision into five-star reality on a remote Caribbean island.”


Awards
- 2025
- U.S. News & World Report, Gold Badge, No. 4 Best Hotels in the British Virgin Islands
- 2023
- World Travel Awards, British Virgin Islands’ Leading Resort
- 2022
- World Travel Awards, World’s Leading Marina Resort, nomination
- World Travel Awards, Caribbean’s Leading Luxury Island Resort, nomination
- World Travel Awards, British Virgin Islands’ Leading Resort, nomination
- TripAdvisor, Travellers’ Choice Award
- 2021
- World Travel Awards, World’s Leading Marina Resort, nomination
- World Travel Awards, Caribbean’s Leading Luxury Island Resort, nomination
- World Travel Awards, British Virgin Islands’ Leading Resort, nomination
- TripAdvisor, Travellers’ Choice Award
- U.S. News & World Report, Gold Badge, Best Hotels in the Caribbean
- 2020
- World Travel Awards, British Virgin Islands’ Leading Resort
- World Travel Awards, World’s Leading Marina Resort, nomination
- World Travel Awards, Caribbean’s Leading Luxury Island Resort, nomination
- Condé Nast Traveler Readers’ Choice Awards, The Best Resorts, Caribbean
- 2019
- U.S. News & World Report, Best Hotel in the BVI
- TripAdvisor Hall of Fame, Certificate of Excellence
- 2017
- AAA, Four Diamond
- U.S. News & World Report, Best Autograph Collection Hotels
- U.S. News & World Report, Best British Virgin Islands Hotels
- Luxury Travel Guide, Luxury Beachfront Hotel of the Year
- 2015
- TripAdvisor Hall of Fame, Certificate of Excellence
- Travel + Leisure, 500 World’s Best Hotels
- 2014
- Travel + Leisure, World’s Best Family Hotel in the Caribbean
- Condé Nast Traveler, Best Spas in the World
- Condé Nast Traveler, World’s Dreamiest Private Island Resorts
- Huffington Post, World’s Dreamiest Private Island Resorts
- Good Morning America, Best Private Marina Hotels
- ABC News, Best Private Marina Hotels
